Indianapolis Colts 2024 Preview

The Indianapolis Colts enter the 2024 season with an over/under win total of 8.5 after finishing 9-8 in 2023. Considering they were led by a rookie head coach and a rookie quarterback who got injured early in the season, their performance was impressive.

Now, with key players returning and some new additions, the Colts are looking to take the next step forward.

Key Insights and Team Overview

The Colts are banking on the continued development of their young quarterback and the strength of their defensive front. Here’s a breakdown of their offensive and defensive outlooks:

Offensive Outlook

Anthony Richardson’s Return:
- Potential Breakout Year: Richardson only played four games last season before getting injured, but he showed flashes of his dual-threat ability, throwing three touchdowns and rushing for three more. His ability to make plays with both his arm and legs makes him a dynamic threat. If he can stay healthy, he could take a significant leap in 2024.
Receiving Corps:
- Michael Pittman Jr.: Pittman continues to be the focal point of the Colts’ passing attack, leading the team with over 1,100 yards and four touchdowns last season. His chemistry with Richardson will be crucial.
- Josh Downs and Alec Pierce: Downs had a solid season as the secondary option with nearly 800 yards, while Pierce added over 500 yards. The addition of rookie Adonai Mitchell, a highly athletic receiver, could push Pierce for reps and add another dimension to the offense.
- Tight End Production: Kylen Granson returns after a modest season with 368 yards and a touchdown. He’ll need to step up as a reliable target in the middle of the field.
Running Game:
- Jonathan Taylor’s Impact: Taylor missed a significant portion of last season but still managed to produce when he was on the field. A healthy Taylor, combined with Richardson’s mobility, could make for a dangerous backfield duo. If Taylor can return to his All-Pro form, the Colts’ offense will have a solid foundation.
Offensive Line:
- Mixed Performance: The Colts’ offensive line was inconsistent last year, with left tackle Bernhard Raimann allowing 8.5 sacks. However, the rest of the line performed well, particularly guards Quenton Nelson and Will Fries. Bringing back all five starters from a group that PFF rated as the sixth-best in the league is a positive sign for continuity and improvement.

Defensive Outlook

Defensive Line and Pass Rush:
- Strength in the Trenches: The Colts’ front seven is the strength of their defense, finishing fifth in the NFL with 51 sacks last season. DeForest Buckner remains a force in the middle, and Kwity Paye continues to develop as a pass rusher. The addition of Samson Ebukam, who led the team with 9.5 sacks, and rookie Latu Latu, considered one of the most natural pass rushers in the draft, should only bolster this unit.
Linebackers:
- Tackling Machines: Zaire Franklin was a tackling machine last season with nearly 180 tackles, and his partner, E.J. Speed, contributed over 100 tackles. This duo will be key in maintaining the Colts’ solid run defense, which allowed 4.1 yards per carry last year.
Secondary Concerns:
- Mixed Results: The Colts’ secondary had a subpar year, with several cornerbacks giving up high passer ratings. However, safety Julian Blackman was a bright spot, leading the team with four interceptions and holding quarterbacks to a low 40s passer rating. The Colts will need better play from the rest of the secondary, including Kenny Moore and the young cornerbacks who struggled last season.

Season Outlook

The Colts are a team with potential but also some uncertainties, particularly in the secondary and with the development of Anthony Richardson. Here’s a look at their potential floor and ceiling:

Win Total Floor: 6 Wins
- Why? If Richardson struggles or gets injured again, the Colts could find themselves in a tough spot. However, they should still be able to pick up wins against weaker opponents like the Steelers, Patriots, and Broncos, leading to a 6-11 finish.
Win Total Ceiling: 10 Wins
- Why? If Richardson stays healthy and takes a significant step forward, the Colts could be a playoff contender. Sweeping the Titans and picking up key wins against teams like the Bills and Bears could see them finish with a 10-7 record.

Final Thoughts

The Indianapolis Colts are a team with a bright future, especially if Anthony Richardson can develop into the star quarterback they believe he can be. Their defense, particularly the front seven, should keep them competitive in most games. The key to their season will be the progression of their young players and how well the secondary can hold up against some of the top passing offenses they’ll face.

Key Points Recap

Anthony Richardson’s health and development are crucial to the Colts’ success in 2024.
Michael Pittman Jr. and Jonathan Taylor are the key offensive playmakers, but contributions from rookies like Adonai Mitchell could make a big difference.
The defensive front seven is strong, but the secondary needs to improve for the Colts to reach their full potential.
Win total projection: 6 to 10 wins, depending on Richardson’s development and the performance of the secondary.

Colts fans, get ready for an intriguing season—there’s plenty of potential in this team, and with some breaks going their way, they could be in the mix for the playoffs once again!

Subscribe to our newsletter